In the Valley of ElahA 90-minute Oscar wanna-be  September 12,
2007 4:15:18 PM
![INSIDEinthevalleyofelah[1]](/secure/uploadedImages/The_Phoenix/Movies/Reviews/INSIDEinthevalleyofelah[1].jpg "INSIDEinthevalleyofelah[1]")
IN THE VALLEY OF ELAH: No social or political problem too complicated.
|
No social or political problem is so complicated that Paul Haggis can’t reduce it to a glib, manipulative, 90-minute Oscar wanna-be. Post traumatic stress disorder and the consequences of the war in Iraq are more clear-cut subjects than racism in LA, so he needs only one story line to hammer home his simplistic conclusions. Tommy Lee Jones puts in a simmering performance (say what you will, Haggis brings the best out of actors) as Hank, an Army vet whose son has gone AWOL while on leave. Playing detective, Hank studies his son’s corrupted video files for clues, an activity that affords Haggis some gratuitous Blow-Up indulgences. When the case intensifies, Hank testily teams up with local cop Emily Sanders (Charlize Theron), and the solution proves more tendentious than suspenseful. Few will deny that the war dehumanizes, but Haggis’s suggestion that everybody who comes back is a sociopath won’t win many friends.
|
 |
|
- Our critics pick the 14 producers with the fattest, meanest beats
- Ben is back with Gone Baby Gone
- Never mind its tough-girl alt-porn feminism: SuicideGirls has already moved on to a new generation
- Comic timing
- Steve Albini speaks
- In his bid for re-election, city councilor Stephen Murphy has collected a combustible group of allies, from Dapper to Deval
- Evangelicals are speaking in bubbles — and fighting God’s war on pop culture
- Kerry Stuart Coppin’s images of Africa and beyond
- Lessons from the build-them-up, tear-them-down Boston firefighter backlash
- Kick him when he's down
- Freedom watch
- Music seen at the Cumberland County Civic Center, October 4, 2007
|
-
Hoary high-camp clichés
-
Ben is back with Gone Baby Gone
-
Kitch, clichés, and neurosis — a fatal combination
-
The films of Michael Haneke at the HFA and MFA
-
Darjeeling is limited but rewarding
-
Lee approaches Lust with Caution
-
Ang Lee goes NC-17
-
A tale of a megalomaniac as told by a narcissist
-
Aching with ambiguity
-
Let the carnage begin!
|
- Resolutely weird
- On a diabetic throne
- Michael Caine remaking Michael Caine
- The Honda Accord of movies
- Unintentional sports comedy
- Haunting agony and angst
- Hoary high-camp clichés
- Another African-American life lesson
- Wry desperation in Buenos Aires
- Ben is back with Gone Baby Gone
|
|
|
|